Projected PER, stars and busts

Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby discovery69 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 5:55 am

I'm going to find some of the NBA Analyst projections of players into next week, but I like to kick off with one of the best geeks when it comes to number crunching. Hollinger's annual PER projection....

ESPN Insider John Hollinger has a long article on his rating of players in the draft. Probably shouldn't copy the whole article since it is a paid site and don't want to get ClubBlazer in trouble, but will provide a summary

Hollinger’s “Player Efficiency Rating (PER) Projection” - has a very complex formula he uses for projecting who will be all-stars, team stars, starters, role players and busts. His formula has shown to be very accurate in the past, but even he admits he has to adjust his formula for players that deliver even though they didn’t project to have a good PER (i.e. Isaiah Thomas last year picked last).

He not only takes the PER Projection, but also items the PER Projection can’t take into account with defensive plus or minuses; red flags on health and mental (i.e. desire, attitude) and a couple of other subjective calls he doesn’t go into.

Here is a breakdown:
  • Anthony Davis (22.23) – only real star of the draft and probably rookie of year player.
  • Dion Waiters (14.12) and Michael Kidd-Gilchrist (13.58) with a rating above 13 for SG/SF is considered very good / potential all-stars as his past 8 players PERs have done well with 5 played in the all-star game. Waiters is projected to be the best small wing (i.e. SG/SF) since Dwayne Wade. Quincy Miller (12.94) despite his poor performance at the combine and some of the workouts due to his body not completely healed from his ACL is still projected to be a top ten player in the draft and will be a great pick in the 20’s once he is recovered from his ACL.
  • PGs – Kendall Marshall (13.84), Marquis Teague (13.18), Tony Wroten (12.21) – are top three PGs of the draft, but no real stars and the best value is to pick these players in the lower half of the first round. Marshall is the safe pick, but least upside to improve. Wroten has the most star upside, but can a team harness his talent. Teague is a talented score first PG, but limited on court vision.
  • Next top PF/C are Jared Sullinger (16.86), Thomas Robinson (16.86), Draymond Green (14.84), Terrence Jones (14.28), Royce White (14.07), Furkan Aldemir (12.87), John Henson (12.11), Andre Drummond (12.05) and Henry Sims (10.38). Henson and Drummond rate low in PERs, because of their lack of offense, but it is their defense the PER doesn’t take into account. Drummond is projected to be a top defensive player in the draft and that is why he is rated in the top 5 for how valuable he will be to a team looking for a defensive big man.
  • Potential busts due to weak college schedule of opponents or not projected to have much upside or a team may pick them too high in the draft and not get the value. Damian Lillard (9.75) best value is mid to late 1st round (ouch-just say “NO” blazers). Andrew Nicolson (8.22), John Jenkins (7.76), Moe Harkless (7.15), and Arnett Moultrie (6.42) if a team picks them in the 1st round will be disappointed. Players like Maalik Wayns (8.02), Hollis Thompson (8.01), Jae Crowder (7.90), Jared Cunningham (7.76), Scott Machado (7.57), Darius Miller (6.65) are good value picks in the 2nd round, but don’t expect them to be starters.
  • Projected value – Perry Jones (8.77) at PF is rated low on the PER, but doesn’t say what happens if he is rated at SF. Tyler Zeller (8.23), Fab Melo (7.73), Meyers Leonard (7.02), Festius Ezeli (6.54) are projected in 2nd half of 1st round to early 2nd round.
discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Re: ESPN Insider - Draft Rater by Projected PER

Postby discovery69 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 5:58 am

Here is Hollinger's projected players that should be drafted based on potential, red flags (i.e. health and mental) and defensive deficiencies....

Adding from John Hollingers previous PER projections - All-star, Team star (top 3-4 on a team), starter, 6th-7th man, bench warmer, and not in the league in 3-5 years.
    All-star
    1. Anthony Davis

    All-star to Team Star
    2. Thomas Robinson
    3. Michael Kidd-Gilchrist
    4. Dion Waiters
    5. Andre Drummond

    Team Star to Starter
    6. Quincy Miller
    7. Jared Sullinger
    8. Terrence Jones
    9. John Henson
    10. Royce White

    Starter to 6th/7th man
    11. Bradley Beal
    12. Harrison Barnes
    13. Tony Wroten
    14. Kendall Marshall
    15. Marquis Teague
    16. Draymond Green
    17. Jeremy Lamb
    18. Damian Lillard
    19. Austin Rivers
    20. Doron Lamb

    6th-7th man - rotation
    21. Furkan Aldemir
    22. Will Barton
    23. Tyler Zeller
    24. Evan Fournier
    25. Tyshawn Taylor
    26. Meyers Leonard
    27. Terrence Ross
    28. Perry Jones
    29. Festus Ezeli
    30. Fab Melo

    Rotation - bench warmer
    31. Kostas Sloukas
    32. Henry Sims
    33. Terrell Stoglin
    34. Kostas Papanikolaou
    35. Moe Harkless
    36. Leon Radosevic
    37. JaMychal Green
    38. Andrew Nicholson
    39. Drew Gordon
    40. Garrett Stutz

    Bench warmer to not in the league in 3 years
    41. Robert Sacre
    42. Arnett Moultrie
    43. William Buford
    44. Jae Crowder
    45. Jared Cunningham
    46. Jordan Taylor
    47. John Jenkins
    48. Orlando Johnson
    49. Jeffrey Taylor
    50. Tomas Satoransky

    Not in the league in 3-5 years
    51. Quincy Acy
    52. Maalik Wayns
    53. Tornike Shengelia
    54. Scott Machado
    55. Mike Scott
    56. J'Covan Brown
    57. Reggie Hamilton
    58. Khris Middleton
    59. Tony Mitchell
    60. Miles Plumlee
discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby discovery69 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 8:34 am

Jay Bilas, ESPN Insider, published an article on June 13th, called “Five prospects with star potential”

Here is a summary:

Real guaranteed star in draft
    Anthony Davis

Stars in draft
  • Bradley Beal – Ray Allen type player, 6’8” wingspan, versatile and efficient shooter around the floor, can defend and rebound.
  • Michael Kidd-Gilchrist – Will to win is contagious. Defend from athletic PGs to PFs. 7 ft wingspan, 35 inch vertical. Energy player 100% of the time. May not be an all-star but a team star.
  • Harrison Barnes – Has size, length and very good athleticism. Outstanding jump-shooter, good ball skills, can drive to the hole, terrific defender. Projected as better pro then in college.
  • Jeremy Lamb – 6’11” wingspan, high release which allows him to shoot over shorter SGs, can move without the ball and create his own shot. Projected as better pro than in college.

Potential Stars – great upside, but need work to fill holes
  • Jared Sullinger – he knows how to play his position. 31 inch vertical, 7’1” wingspan. Needs to hit the 20ft shot, struggles against taller players.
  • Royce White – PG in a defensive lineman body. Offensive versatility and passing are his strengths. Anxiety disorder will cause team concerns.
  • Andre Drummond – a beast, he has every tool you want in a player except shooting. Huge, can run, rebound, block shots and alter shots. A junior Dwight Howard. How bad does he want to improve is the major question. If he is willing to work at it in the gym, he will be a major star in the NBA, if not, just an average center.
  • Perry Jones III – great kid who has every tool in a player you want. When he plays well, the sky is the limit with his potential. Bilas recommends taking a chance on him as he will be worth the risk in the lottery. Areas to improve are toughness, leadership and “want to”.
  • Meyers Leonard – has every tool you want to be a great center except questions on his toughness. Bilas is not concerned about his toughness. Leonard has a nice shooting touch, can rebound and block shots and should be a terrific NBA player.
  • Austin Rivers – very good with the ball, uncanny ability to get past defenders and get into the lane, should do very well in the NBA with it’s rules that protect smaller players. Very good offensive weapon, but still needs to improve his range; needs to improve his ball handling and passing. Some complain about his “cockiness”, but that is because he wants to win and should be a very good NBA player.
discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Billy on Wed Jun 20, 2012 8:50 am

I was against the idea of Portland using these picks for a long time. But if Portland can't acquire a big name, the draft is definitely the way to go.

I think Portland definitely has a shot at 2 of those "All-star to Team Star" guys. If Portland could somehow land 2 of those guys and maybe pluck someone like Sullinger, Teague, or Wroten with a late first, that would be a very good draft.

Definitely am liking the idea of Drummond. Waiters is certainly growing on me..
Billy
ClubBlazers Community Moderator
 
Posts: 336
Joined: Thu Jul 31, 2008 6:57 am

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Murrog on Wed Jun 20, 2012 1:26 pm

If Drummond's upside is a an all-star, and his downside is average NBA center, he should be a no-brainer for us at 6 if he is still there.
Murrog
All-Star
 
Posts: 1249
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:13 am

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Toby on Wed Jun 20, 2012 1:39 pm

Babbitt's gonna put on 50lbs of solid muscle, and become a dominate paint player, while still retaining his Chalupa special 3 point shot.
User avatar
Toby
Coach
 
Posts: 2929
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 6:23 pm
Location: Let's Go Blazers

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby discovery69 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 2:02 pm

http://nbadraft.net/boom-or-bust-prospects
Boom or Bust Prospects
By Jonathan_Wasserman
Wed, 06/20/2012 - 10:24pm

One of the most challenging decisions for NBA evaluators is weighing risk versus reward. Projecting ceilings and basements while measuring the likelihood of each is an integral part of the draft evaluation process. Depending on the direction of a team and its current personnel, prospects with towering upside who remain vulnerable to underachieving could be unappealing as a top selection, especially when you consider the value of a high pick. On the other hand, teams looking to roll the dice might want to take a chance on a "Boom or Bust" prospect, with the hopes that their ceiling is reached and a star is born in time. Here's a list of some of the riskiest yet most rewarding prospects in the 2012 NBA draft.

Andre Drummond
Andre DrummondWhile it's not as black and white as Kwame Brown or Dwight Howard, Drummond's projections land at the opposite ends of the spectrum. On one hand, if Drummond develops some go-to moves and revs up that motor, he becomes the immediate focus of a defense's attention. A guy the opposition game-plans for. A double-team requirement. Then again if he fails to develop offensively, he becomes limited to finishing and clean-up duties. Though nice to have, that doesn't justify top 5 value.

Perry Jones
We look at Jones and see incredible potential based on the height of a center and athleticism of a guard. And not only that, but Jones can play the game. He's a good basketball player. The issue is whether or not Jones can strategically use his strengths to exploit the mismatch he presents. He could end up being like no player we've seen. Or he can end up lost between positions, like Anthony Randolph.

Jeremy Lamb
Lamb is the most dynamic perimeter scorer in the field when you consider his ability to create and make shots out to 25 feet. We've seen glimpses of explosiveness attacking the rim off two feet. Plus his midrange game is well refined. But his competitive drive isn't overwhelming, and neither is his frame. Lamb could be vulnerable to getting pushed around by stronger, meaner two-guards, which would restrict him from getting within 15 feet of the rim. On the bright side, 15-25 feet is his area of comfort. On the dark side, more than half of his field goal attempts came from behind the arc, where he shot a disappointing 33%.

Terrence Jones
Few players can match his physical dimensions and skill set. At 6'9, 252 and with a 7'2 wingspan, Jones has the ability to run the floor and create. He's an automatic mismatch problem for opposing teams, due to his ability to face the basket and pull opposing bigmen away from the paint. But questions persist about his motor and focus. His body language is not always the greatest and he's had a few meltdown games in which his mental state appeared to be somewhere between Neptune and Pluto. If he realizes his potential he's a top 10 prospect, but he also has a real bust potential which has his stock somewhere in the mid-first round area.

Meyers Leonard
On paper, the kid's tools could build a skyscraper. He's 7'1 with a developed NBA body. Athletic and talented. But centers are always vulnerable to underachieving due to a drastic transition process playing inside. At the college level, baskets come easy for 7-footers, primarily because their defender is generally 6'10 or smaller. At the pro level, Leonard will be required to body up against stronger, more athletic men his size- keyword: men. Leonard could end up being a top three scoring option, or if he could end up as a backup space-eater- the difference between a steal and a reach.

Royce White
A unique game with enormous talent, White could be mismatch or a misfit. A small forward with point guard instincts and power forward strength, White could take on an array of responsibilities, therefore diminishing the impact of lacking depth, versatility and balance. White could overpower small forwards and beat 4s off the dribble. Or it could work the other way, in which 3s are too quick for him and power forwards are too big.

Quincy Miller
He's got lottery talent to go with a size advantage at the 3 position. However his high school ACL injury prevented him from turning the corner on his defender, forcing him to develop a midrange game in which he now excels at. If he ever gains back his explosiveness, Miller could end up with the full-offensive half court package. If he struggles to separate from NBA defenders, generating points on a consistent basis could be a challenge at the next level.

Tony Wroten
Wroten's athleticism is tailor-made for basketball, and at 6'6, he's the ideal shape and size for a guard. He needs to work on a specific craft, whether it's shooting or playmaking, but this combo of size and athleticism could propel him to another level. Then again we've seen phenomenal athletes out of the job after just a few years.

discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Kmurph1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 2:45 pm

Hey D69, any info about the not so "secret" workout tomorrow?
Kmurph1
Starter
 
Posts: 333
Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2008 8:45 pm

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby discovery69 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 9:19 pm

Kmurph1 wrote:Hey D69, any info about the not so "secret" workout tomorrow?


I haven't. These workouts are so close to the vest, that Olshey only has a few trusted people who know a week in advance. So my contact(s) only can tell me how the workouts went, but not who is coming. So I've been trying to find out through articles :cry1:
discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Fez on Wed Jun 20, 2012 9:42 pm

I'd guess it's Robinson or MKG.

D69, have you heard of the interest in Waiters?
User avatar
Fez
6th man
 
Posts: 277
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2008 5:23 pm

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Kmurph1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 10:17 pm

Robinson's twitter says he is in CHA tomorrow.....
Kmurph1
Starter
 
Posts: 333
Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2008 8:45 pm

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby TBpup on Wed Jun 20, 2012 10:32 pm

have you heard of the interest in Waiters?


Fez....some interest but gauging what might do is difficult. He is a 6'3", 220lb wrecking ball that has some very unique offensive skills but but gaps in others and weight is a concern.
TBpup
Starter
 
Posts: 372
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2007 8:44 pm
Location: Beaverton/Lake Oswego

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby TBpup on Thu Jun 21, 2012 6:23 am

@JustBlaze52: If Drummond falls to #6 I bet that the Blazers will take him...
@mikerice6: Wanna bet
_________________________________________________
@kede23: if the Blazers select Drummond, you're going to say all this to his face right?
@mikerice6: never will have to
_________________________________________________
@PDXKass: Drummond or Lillard at 6; who else might we pick?
@mikerice6: forget drummond. Dropping
_________________________________________________
@BlazerWookee: I heard drummond lacks motivation?
@mikerice: its a little more than that
_________________________________________________
@ranKismet: rivers? Thumb up or down at 11? Would love him and Drummond for #Blazers.
@mikerice6: forget drummond
_________________________________________________
@KwameLuvThaKids: If drummond is there at 11, would you take him?
@mikerice6: No
_________________________________________________
@jhassler80: If Drummond slips to 11 then is he worth the risk? Don't think he will but...
@mikerice6: he will slip. Even lower
_________________________________________________
@mmeewes: you say "yes" when the guy said Drummond. Does that mean you are sailing his ship now?
@mikerice6: no way. Never
_________________________________________________
@celticwarrior80: trade #6 pick and one 2nd round to move up to get Andre Drummond is that a little insane???
@mikerice6: dont like him


Apparently Mike Rice doesn't think much of Drummond's PER... :boo:
TBpup
Starter
 
Posts: 372
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2007 8:44 pm
Location: Beaverton/Lake Oswego

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby Khazim on Thu Jun 21, 2012 9:19 pm

Kmurph1 wrote:Hey D69, any info about the not so "secret" workout tomorrow?

Was there some kind of workout today? Haven't seen any info...
User avatar
Khazim
Bench
 
Posts: 109
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2008 6:55 pm

Re: Projected PER, stars and busts

Postby discovery69 on Fri Jun 22, 2012 9:59 am

Khazim wrote:
Kmurph1 wrote:Hey D69, any info about the not so "secret" workout tomorrow?

Was there some kind of workout today? Haven't seen any info...


:blink: No one is talking, because there is rumors that the Blazers had a private workout, but not at the Blazer facility. I'm trying to find out if Olshey was out of town.
discovery69
ClubBlazers.com Administrator
 
Posts: 4983
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 5:14 am
Location: Hillsboro, OR

Next

Return to Blazers Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 1 guest

Advertise Here | Privacy Policy | ©2008 Sculu Sports. Come Strong.